The "not-so-secret" recipe: what's cooking with Third-Party cookies?

Huzaifa Arif
Technology5 mins read
Cookie Blog.png

Imagine you're at a dinner party, and your host introduces you to their friend, who follows you all evening and takes notes on everything you do.

Creepy, right?

Third-party cookies are like nosy party guests but in the digital realm. They're small text files created by websites other than the one you're currently visiting.

Their primary job? To track your online behaviour across different sites, helping advertisers build a detailed profile of your interests, habits, and possibly even what you had for breakfast (okay, maybe not that last part).

How cookies work (and why you may be getting indigestion).

Let's follow Sarah, our intrepid online shopper, as she navigates the treacherous waters of e-commerce:

  • Sarah visits "OutdoorGear.com" to check out some hiking boots.
  • Unknown to Sarah, OutdoorGear.com uses "AdNetwork.com" to display ads.
  • AdNetwork.com sets a third-party cookie in Sarah's browser.
  • Later, Sarah visits a travel blog that also uses AdNetwork.com.
  • The cookie recognizes Sarah, tracking her activity across both sites.
  • AdNetwork.com builds a profile of Sarah, noting her interest in hiking gear and travel.
  • When Sarah visits a news site, she's served ads for hiking boots and camping gear.

Sounds convenient. Well, not everyone's thrilled about this digital stalking.

Privacy advocates argue that this level of tracking is invasive and can lead to the creation of detailed user profiles without explicit consent. It's like having a personal paparazzi, but instead of catching you in embarrassing situations, they're cataloguing your every click and purchase.

How the bakers (browsers) are handling the heat.

As users have become more privacy-conscious, major browsers have started to address the third-party cookie conundrum:

  • Safari — Went full Marie Kondo and decided third-party cookies don't spark joy. They have been blocked by default since 2020.
  • Firefox — Followed suit, telling third-party cookies, "You can't sit with us".
  • Google Chrome — The popular kid who couldn't decide whether to join the fantastic privacy club or stick with its ad-loving friends.

That one friend who always says they'll start their diet "next week."

Google Chrome initially announced plans to phase out third-party cookies by 2022. But like most New Year's resolutions, this timeline kept getting pushed back: 2023, 2024, 2025…

Why the cold feet, Google? Well, it turns out that when you're both a primary browser and a significant player in the digital advertising world, things get a bit… complicated.

Google's cookie jar is filled with good intentions but messy realities.

  • Eliminating third-party cookies could impact their bottom line more than other browser vendors.
  • The online advertising system is very complex. Changing one part could cause issues for the whole system.
  • Creating new methods that protect user privacy but still allow companies to show targeted ads is more complex than it may seem.
  • Getting the entire industry to agree on and use new standards is exceptionally challenging.

Google’s new recipe: Have your cookie and eat it too.

They announced in July 2024 that instead of showing third-party cookies the door, they're giving users the keys to the cookie jar.

  • Third-party cookies get a stay of execution: They're sticking around in Chrome for now. It's like that house guest who was supposed to stay for a week but is now part of the family.
  • Introducing the "Choose Your Adventure" of web browsing: Chrome will get a new interface allowing users to decide whether to enable third-party cookies or use Google's Privacy Sandbox. It's like being asked if you want to be tracked by a cookie or… a slightly different kind of cookie.
  • Privacy Sandbox continues to be a thing: Google will keep developing these privacy-enhancing technologies. Think of it as their attempt to create a healthy food that tastes like a regular cookie.
  • Regulators and industry get a seat at the table: Google's discussing this pivot with authorities like the UK's Competition and Markets Authority. It's like inviting the principal to the party to show how responsible you are.

So, what's the aftertaste like?

  • Privacy is complicated: In the digital age, balancing privacy with functionality is as easy as balancing a cookie on your nose.
  • User choice is critical: Google's new approach puts more control in your hands. Use it wisely!
  • The cookie isn't crumbling just yet: Third-party cookies are sticking around but with more transparency about their presence.
  • Stay informed: As the digital landscape evolves, keeping up with privacy settings is becoming as important as updating your password (you do that regularly, right?).

In the end, whether you choose to embrace or reject third-party cookies, remember that the internet is watching, but you get to decide how closely.

Choose wisely, and may your browsing be private and peppered with perfectly personalized ads (or not!).

The choice, dear reader, is yours!

Category
Technology
Published On
26 Sep, 2024
Share

Subscribe to our tech, design & culture updates at Proximity

Weekly updates, insights & news across all teams

Copyright © 2019-2023 Proximity Works™